Tag Archives: Ability Scores

Class Based Ability Scores

A few newer games that use base ability scores are using a mechanic where your race and/or your class actually adjust your randomly generated/point-bought ability scores.  Races have traditionally played this role, but for some reason, classes haven’t.  

So, when thinking about different races, it’s easy classical to define that race by what makes them different than being human – and that almost always tends to relate to the core ability scores.  They’re like a human, but stronger, or like a human but wiser.  A race is something you are – and your ability scores are often the primary vehicle for enumerating “what you are.”

Classes, on the other hand, have traditionally been about what you do.  So your class defines the abilities you gain as you advance in experience and training.  I think because of this dichotomy, classes haven’t traditionally been tapped with the duty of adjusting starting ability scores.

Still, I think I like this new direction.  If you close your eyes and think about a fighter, or a thief, or a wizard, you’re probably not just envisioning a set of skills, you’re likely also thinking about a strong, a quick, or a smart hero.  From a play balance and design perspective, it recognizes that if I pick a fighter, I probably want to play a strong character.  Since we know up front in the design that strength is probably a pretty important characteristic for a fighter, it’s nice to help make sure new fighters aren’t too gimped from the get-go and help give the player what they’re envisioning when they decided to play that type of character.

Another nice thing this can do is help represent the years of training that went on before a character became a first level thief.  When you start thinking about multi-classing, and a character with 8 years of apprenticeship in the local thieves guild starts dabbling in magic, why would they be just as good at each.  That extra bit of ability score for your first level class can help, if only a bit, differentiate your first class with all that background from any class switches over time.

So, I think I’ll probably give each class a bonus point to a statistic that’s primary to that class.  That ability will either be chosen for you, or I’ll give the player a choice between two (like Strength OR Vitality) for a Barbarian.


Random Stat Generation

I know that some people like the randomization that comes with rolling your stats.  There main philosophies boil down to:

1. Total Point Buy is as even as it can get.  You get full customization options and you’re never left behind.  This is the character-first method.

2. Rolling a character helps you build a character organically.  You create a character from what you’re given, rather than from some starting concept.  This is the stats first method.  A subset of this method believes that you should generate scores completely randomly, where the averages make you a normal person, so that you can start from humble beginnings or overcome serious deficiencies.

Continue reading

First Draft: Ability Scores

The ability scores are tentatively set.  I think I will tentatively rate them on a 10 scale, at least for now.  If I move the core mechanic around, that scale might change.  I think that a 10 would be something like a Giant or a Dragon, and a high strength for a normal human would be somewhere around 6 or 7.  I don’t think of each step as an even increment, I think of each step as something closer to a standard deviation.  The average human score would be a 3 or 4, with standard deviations going up or down from there.

Continue reading